155 Comments

The New Yorker writer implying Sinead O’Connor “fought capitalism” with a haircut...

“Is this what college Marxism has become?”

Yes, this is exactly what college Marxism has become, and I’m starting to believe that’s all it ever was: Empty Aesthetic.

Expand full comment
Aug 1, 2023Liked by Matt Welch

Big "eat your podcast or I'll give you something to cry about" energy

Expand full comment
founding
Aug 1, 2023Liked by Matt Welch

I think the group’s patience should be rewarded with one picture of Moynihan paying €400 (minimum) per day, for a Cabana at one of the beach clubs in Forte dei Marmi.

God knows we will hear about it.

Expand full comment

Moynihan is just like BLM. He takes our subscription fees and blows it on the high life.

Expand full comment

The case for a producer seems to be ever-growing

Expand full comment

“Troy”, written when Sinead O’Conner was in her teens, is proof of almighty songwriting ability, either the orchestrated album version or just her and an acoustic guitar live, which is brutal. It blew me away aged 17 and it still sounds amazing now.

She also wrote some great songs for her second album. She was a proper songwriter, not someone who worked with five other songwriters and added a couple of words to a song.

I didn’t follow her work much after that, as l got the sense she unravelled (and it wasn’t as easy to follow bands/artists back then, especially as I was a student and CDs weren’t cheap), but that her big hit was a cover should not disguise her talent, before fame took its toll.

If you like songs about heart-wrenching rejection, “Troy” is up there with the best, with added profanity in the live version.

Expand full comment

I have a similar Sinead history. From that time, the key to seeing her as a good songwriter was “The Emperor’s New Clothes”. As confessional and confronting as pop music gets.

Expand full comment

This whole album just rips me up.

Expand full comment

Speaking of Troy...that maxi single re-release in 2002 was stellar...The Push Remix *chef's kiss*

Expand full comment

Three babies 🔥

Expand full comment

Thanks for the tip - I listened to the live version of "Troy," and it's very affecting.

I'm not a music maven, so I don't have the vocabulary to express this well, and my opinion probably isn't that insightful, but here goes:

1) IMHO, the songwriting on Troy probably isn't that memorable, but the performance is awesome.

2) What I found affecting about the performance is that it's very raw in contrast with her very pretty voice, plus there is the trademark O'Conner thing where her voice "breaks" and jumps notes in the middle of a syllable, which gives the whole thing an authentic, mad quality.

Expand full comment

No. She's "just a pretty bald girl with a pretty voice." sarcasm.

Why am I not surprised? Micheal did exactly what he accused the leftist writer of the article of doing: he'll only hold artists in high regard if their politics are to the right. Consider the breathless praise over Nick Cave.

Expand full comment

I just think it seemed like MM hadn't listened to enough Sinead O'Conner and drew an inference about her most famous hit being a cover. She may have had other covers later too that adds to this, but I'm talking about the early years.

She wrote 5 genuinely great songs on the second album, and "Troy", from the first, will forever be amongst my favourite songs. And as I said, I'm not a fan of her's per se, but you could see the songwriting talent at a young age. I don't know what she wrote later in life, and how it compares (no pun intended).

Live version here, mixing gentle (genuine) vulnerability with a fearsome rage, from 1988:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JeIHZvZTJTg

"You should have left the light on – then I'd never have tried and you'd never have known"

Expand full comment

I was thinking something similar when he kept mentioning Mandinka as being "the single from The Lion and the Cobra", and thinking, "who cares about Mandinka?"

Expand full comment
founding

Au contraire mon frère…if you’ve not heard this Eli Lake episode with one Michael Moynihan, it’s pretty good:

https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-re-education-with-eli-lake/id1619523910?i=1000569875210

They discuss the ill politics of their favorite artists (The Clash, Rage, Elvis Costello, Billy Bragg, etc.), and why politics are a ridiculous reason to not listen to artists you love. And yes, Moynihan loves Nick Cave, but I’m pretty sure that was well-established before he knew his politics, not the other way around.

Expand full comment
founding

I need to catch up my my Re-education. That sounds great. I used to love Rage as a teenage lefty (though I was never as lefty as them, hah) and I still do, even though their politics are the worst.

Expand full comment
founding

Between Moynihan and Eli, they cover a lot of ground in that episode! Eli also did an extended punk episode with Nick Gillespie last summer that was pretty interesting. Totally with you on Rage--I'll happily listen to them any day of the week so long as it's not an interview with Tom Morello. :)

Expand full comment
founding

The upside to commuting is lots of listen time. Got through it today - thanks for the suggestion!

Expand full comment
founding

Anytime, my friend!

Expand full comment

I do think he under-sold her as a songwriter (yep, she was good, not great - but several songs were fucking great), but c'mon. Westerberg's isn't what anyone would consider on the right (nor is Cave, but less so). Nor would I necessarily consider Shuhada' Sadaqat on the left. And the bit of the article attributing her music etc. to the battle against Capitalism was flat out dumb. If anything it was a battle to control her individuality.

Expand full comment
Aug 2, 2023Liked by Matt Welch

Nancy Mace 2024: It’s Morning in America, Baby!

Expand full comment
founding
Aug 1, 2023·edited Aug 1, 2023Liked by Matt Welch

That Cathy Young column was so weird. The underlying argument of exploring Republican affection for RFK was valid, but then she chose the worst avatar imaginable to make it in Cooke. And then just doubled down over and over. As someone who respects her writing that just sucked to watch

Expand full comment

I can’t blame CC for being upset, especially in light of her dismissive response.

Expand full comment

Obviously with all the saucer crashes we can assume that the alien pilots were DEI hires and that's a big problem all over the Galaxy

Expand full comment

Diversity, Equity, and Invasion

Expand full comment

Very good! Wish I’d thought of that.

Expand full comment

DETI

Expand full comment
founding

Maybe we only see the little green men because the little blue men have better piloting skills.

Expand full comment

Great (if apocryphal) line about the demise of Loeb (of Leopold and Loeb referenced at the start) who was murdered in prison after apparently coming onto another inmate in the 1930's:

"Despite his erudition and good upbringing, today Mr Loeb ended his sentence with a proposition"

Expand full comment

On a business trip out west, I saw a guy with a Obama change style shirt except it was Thomas sowell not Obama. This seemed the right place to share.

Expand full comment

A better design would be 'Hope', since Sowell's philosophy begets that emotion in me much more than Obama's cringe-y 'Victimhood with a side of mashed bootstraps' bloviation.

Expand full comment

Omg

Expand full comment

Right? I think he was a little embarrassed by how much I kvelled over him

Expand full comment

And hopefully you also found out where I can get one?

Expand full comment

I got you. https://www.teepublic.com/t-shirt/19207933-thomas-sowell-in-colour

I recently purchased a "don't make me use my nuclear engineer voice" t shirt so I've maxed my kitschy tshirts budget

Expand full comment

Sinead O'Connor did a lot of amazing renditions of traditional Irish songs and collaborations with great bands, like the Chieftains, and of course she's most well known in the US for that Prince song. She wrote or co-wrote every song on The Lion and the Cobra, including Jackie, Jerusalem, Troy, and Drink Before the War. These may not be the songs she is most known for, so while it might be fair to say, "She is not known for being a great song writer", Matt Welch, she wrote some really fucking great songs.

Expand full comment
author

I understand and do not detract away from your fandom! I bought The Lion and the Cobra when it came out, too, and listened to it a lot, and appreciate that it has an audience, and I *really* appreciate her as a character and singer. I don't happen to think her written songs are great, is all, including on Lion, but opinions are like assholes, etc.

Expand full comment
founding

I just quoted a PG-version of this line to my 10-year-old today! Only it was in reference to humor, not music, when some punk at basketball camp told my son he wasn’t funny. It made him laugh, so success!

Expand full comment

The Foggy Dew with The Chieftains. Amazing.

Expand full comment

At some point before all of our ears, Moynihan became Larry David:

“... what the fuck is with all these acorns, fuck... fucking acorns fucking my car up FOR FUCKS SAKE”

Expand full comment
founding

His greatest nemesis

Expand full comment

Yay! What a great birthday gift!

Expand full comment
author

Happy birthday!

Expand full comment

Happy Birthday.

Expand full comment

Happy Birthday! 🎂

Expand full comment

Appreciating the fan service for your one Northern Irish fan. Last week we had 'fenians', this week 'taigs' - you'll have to throw in a 'huns' lest you be accused of favouring one side of the community.

Expand full comment

I am a taig, spelled Teague

Expand full comment

I am a hun, but my sister married a taig and I'm dating one. King Billy turning in his grave.

Expand full comment

Okay, so I hate to be "that guy"(well not totally, because I am about to be that guy), but I have to completely disagree about Sinead's ability as a songwriter. If you are defining her career by Nothing Compares 2 U, not only are you not going deep enough, you are not even scratching the surface. There are hundreds of incredibly talented and amazing artists who never get close to having a hit, but their work still stacks up to anybody's. Sinead's bank account and notoriety were lucky enough to profit from a great remake of a Prince song, but pour through her catalog and there is so much more that she herself personally penned. Troy alone is worth the price of admission.

P.S. Are we saying though that under Socialism the idea of physical attractiveness will be done away with and ugly people will have the ability to get ahead in life just as much? Because I might have to reconsider my opposition to Socialism then.

Expand full comment

Yeah, I was really puzzled by their segment on Sinead O’Conner. It felt oddly dismissive.

Expand full comment

Same. It just felt unnecessarily harsh or, at best, naive.

They can swear they are better than the writer of that "New Yorker" (I believe), but they (mostly Micheal) seemed upset about her politics.

I mean, we're defending the Pope for covering sex abuse because "Islam bad".

Expand full comment

They said it was about the writer and others being a little bit too flowery in their remembrances of her but that's to be expected, it being only days after her passing.

While listening it just struck me as dismissive and quite frankly mean spirited. Especially dismissive of her SNL protest against the Catholic Church and the reasons behind it.

Expand full comment

A little strange too because the boys can and have paid tribute to even more obscure artists that were some of their personal faves upon the artists passing. I know to each his own and if Sinead isn't your thing, she isn't your thing, but to mainly categorize her as a one-hit wonder as if she were Men With Hats or the 1910 Fruitgum Company is to really short shrift her as an artist.

Expand full comment

Hey, hey... Pop Goes The World. 2 Damn Hits for the hatless non-birthing people :-)

Expand full comment

Yeah that's the song I was thinking of. Are you saying Men Without Hats had another hit besides Pop Gies The World? Hmmm, it's not ringing a bell.

Expand full comment

I understand that some writers get carried away, but Sinéad had really hardcore fans, and it's to be expected.

I guess this was response was expected as I saw I predicted this last week.

Expand full comment

I don’t doubt her conviction, but I never took her SNL stunt all that seriously. Certainly not enough that it affected my judgment of her body of creative work.

Expand full comment

Such a hugely under appreciated artist AND SONGWRITER. People who haven't listened to The Lion and the Cobra need to stop what they're doing immediately and go listen.

Expand full comment
founding

Chickens are "Non-human biologics".

Expand full comment

So are the McDonald's chicken Nuggets which that dude was eating when he arrived at the 'crash site'

Expand full comment